Mathews Tire

Own this station? Claim your free listing

84Trust Score|4.6★|1350 Hayden Blvd #51, Elizabeth, PA 15037

SunClosed

Mon-Fri8:30AM-4:30PM

Sat8:30AM-12PM

Inspection Types

✗Cars

✗Motorcycles

✗Trailers

✗Med Trucks

✗Heavy Trucks

✗Heavy Trailers

Directions Website

About This Station

Overview & Pro Tips

Paul Mathews Auto & Tire Store has earned a 4.6⭐ rating from 241 reviews with over 12 years of trusted service in Elizabeth, PA. Customers consistently praise their honest assessments, respectful service, and fair pricing—one reviewer noted they only needed front tires instead of all four. Known for backing warranties and treating customers like family.

Pro Tips

💰 Ask if you really need all four tires replaced—they'll give honest assessments and save you money
⏰ Call ahead for tire installation; one customer waited 1.5 hours without advanced notice
😊 Expect genuine care and respect; staff treats panicked customers with calm professionalism
✅ Their warranty backing goes above and beyond—they stand behind their work